Skemp on two approaches

Respected teacher Good Evening
Here are some of my views regarding the article

By using the term Faux amix, Skemp tried to distinguish between relational understanding and instrumental understanding. He establishes that actually instrumental understanding is not understanding at all. That seems true because ‘rules without reasons’ and only plugging the values can not be taken as understanding. Sometimes we notice that teachers have to finish the syllabus within time and they explain how to plug the values in and get the right answer. Actually, this approach never let the children to become innovative. Their imagination flight remains limited. They make their way through fixed plans only. For instance, in our daily life we see the people who are more dependent on GPS, are often fail to understand even the regional geographical locations because they never tried to think without that.
On the other hand, relational mathematics opens unlimited plans because it clears the concepts. Whether hyperbola is on the paper or in the field, they will recognize if the conceptual structure is clear. The relevance of this paper increases if we take step forward to follow relational mathematics in the class. This is the only way to make them fulfilled with understanding and knowledge.
Thanks Paramvir Singh

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Three Curricula by Elliot Eisner

The Three Curricula That All Schools Teach by Elliot Eisner This is very meaningful article about what our extrinsic and intrinsic curriculum offer and there is something which is not included in the prescribed curriculum, but that is also needed. As I had teaching background back home and I taught in BC as well, I agree with Eisner in many ways.  My first stop is about the rewards which are given by teachers in the class, especially in elementary classes. Eisner calls them “reward junkies” because he believes that we are creating a payoff system for children. I totally agree that such type of extrinsic reinforcement turns into bribery instead of best practice. Here I would like to share an anecdote which I noticed two years ago in a private school of BC.  My younger daughter got some prizes in vocal music from the teacher. On every Saturday, there was a program organised by the management to encourage the children for music. Luckily, my daughter has a sweet voice. I ...
Read more

lesson 3

Paramvir Singh LESSON PLAN 3 Mathematics EDCP 342A Date : December 14, 2017     Room       1213 Topic/learning objectives: After completing this lesson students will explore their deep understanding of the topics of the arithmetic and geometric sequences. The respondents will include more information and feelings. Open ended questions will allow the students to get extra information such as demographic information. Many solutions and many ways of solving the questions would be found. Resources:      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y__p_Vyu-lEhttp://www.mediacollege.com/journalism/interviews/open-ended-questions.html https://www.augusta.k12.va.us/cms/lib/VA01000173/Centricity/Domain/766/chap11.pdf Textbook Pre -Calculus 11 HOOK ·          Write an arithmetic sequence with ...
Read more

Revised lesson plan 3

Paramvir Singh LESSON PLAN 3 Exploring sequence and series ( Open -ended questions) Mathematics EDCP 342A Date : Feb.12, 2017     Room       1213 Topic/learning objectives: After completing this lesson, students will explore their deep understanding of the topics of the arithmetic and geometric sequences. Open ended questions will allow the students to get extra information such as demographic information. Many solutions and many ways of solving the questions would be found. Resources:      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y__p_Vyu-lEhttp://www.mediacollege.com/journalism/interviews/open-ended-questions.html https://www.augusta.k12.va.us/cms/lib/VA01000173/Centricity/Domain/766/chap11.pdf Textbook Pre -Calculus 11 HOOK ·          Teacher will invite the whole class t...
Read more